Heimdall vs Carl-bot.
Carl-bot is brilliant at reaction roles and logging. Heimdall adds tickets, a real dashboard and game-server integrations. Here's how they compare.
Feature by feature.
| Feature | Heimdall | Carl-bot |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free for any server size, no member cap Wins | Free, with limits |
| Moderation | ||
| Reaction roles | Role buttons and menus | Carl-bot's signature feature Wins |
| Automod | Rule-based, plus AI with the Odin add-on | Rule-based |
| Tickets | With a web dashboard Wins | |
| Minecraft integration | Full | |
| Tebex integration | Full | |
| Web dashboard | 24 pages, real-time | A configuration panel |
| Logging | Thorough Wins | |
| Levels and XP | Yes, opt in, with role rewards Wins | Premium only |
From each bot's own documentation and pricing pages.
Who wins where.
Heimdall wins
Tickets with a web dashboard
Heimdall has a full ticket system with a real-time web dashboard, so staff can handle tickets from a browser. Carl-bot doesn't do tickets at all.
Minecraft and Tebex
Full Minecraft integration (account linking, whitelist automation and role sync) and Tebex store integration, which Carl-bot doesn't have.
A generous free plan with no member cap
Every core plugin, the full dashboard and generous limits are free for any server size. When you need more, Premium is one flat £5.99 a month whatever your size.
Carl-bot wins
More mature reaction roles
Reaction roles are Carl-bot's signature feature and have been refined over years, with more advanced options for reaction-based roles.
A longer track record
Carl-bot has been a Discord staple for years, with a proven reliability record and a large, established user base.
A bigger user base
As one of the most popular Discord bots, Carl-bot has a huge community, so there are more guides, resources and people to ask.
Heimdall or Carl-bot?
It depends on your priorities. Heimdall is the better pick for game-server communities that need Minecraft or Tebex, a ticket system with a web dashboard and a generous free plan with every core plugin and no member cap. Carl-bot is better if you mainly need reaction roles and thorough logging from a bot with a long track record.
Yes. Plenty of servers run both: Carl-bot for reaction roles and logging, Heimdall for tickets, moderation and game-server integrations. They work well side by side.
Heimdall has self-assign role buttons and dropdown menus. Carl-bot's reaction roles are more mature and have more advanced options, so if reaction roles are your top priority, Carl-bot has the edge.
Also see Heimdall vs MEE6 or Heimdall vs Ticket Tool, or every bot side by side.
Give Heimdall a go.
It's free for any server size, and it runs happily alongside other bots while you decide.
Opens bot.bifrost.gg in a new tab. Questions first? Ask us in the support Discord (opens in a new tab) or read the docs (opens in a new tab).